Inheritance | Limitations on Inheritance for Unfilial Children: Loss of Inheritance Rights-

首頁 > Our Services > Preparation of Will and Administration of Estate

文章分類Article

Inheritance | Limitations on Inheritance for Unfilial Children: Loss of Inheritance Rights

不孝子女繼承限制：喪失繼承權事由與案例

"Losing inheritance rights is a sensitive and complex issue. In our society, family relationships always play an extremely important role. Parents endure hardships to raise their children from a young age, but it becomes heartbreaking when, upon reaching adulthood, these children neglect their parents. The pain is compounded when these unfilial children later contest for inheritance. This article will explore the legal provisions regarding the loss of inheritance rights and reveal, through the analysis of actual cases, how courts make judgments and rulings in such disputes. Can unfilial children be denied inheritance? How is the loss of inheritance rights defined legally? And how can one prevent related inheritance disputes?

I. Legal Background of Disinheritance for Unfilial Children

Inheritance is a method of property transfer stipulated by law. When a person dies, their property is transferred to heirs as designated by law or a will. According to Civil Code Article 1138, children (direct lineal descendants) are the primary heirs of their parents. However, under certain circumstances, children may lose this right due to specific behaviors.

In the realms of law, society, and family ethics, "unfilial behavior" is seen as a severe act that can lead to the loss of inheritance rights. However, the legal definition of "unfilial" can vary from country to country. Generally, unfilial behaviors may include severe neglect or abuse of parents, long-term failure to fulfill economic or emotional support obligations, intentional harm, or causing significant injury to parents.

When courts determine the existence of unfilial behavior, they may legally strip the child of inheritance rights. This usually requires litigation initiated by other heirs or interested parties, and the court makes a decision based on the specifics of the case. It's worth noting that the loss of inheritance rights due to unfilial behavior is strictly limited and used cautiously, as it involves significant changes to fundamental family relationships and individual rights.

II. Typical Reasons for Loss of Inheritance Rights

In Taiwan, the loss of inheritance rights is triggered by various factors, clearly specified in the Civil Code. Article 1145, Paragraph 1, of the Civil Code contains important regulations regarding the loss of inheritance rights. These reasons primarily include:

Intentional harm leading to the death of the decedent or other heirs: If an heir intentionally causes the death of the decedent (e.g., parents) or other heirs and is convicted, they will lose their inheritance rights, even if the act did not result in death.
Fraud, coercion, and will-related actions: An heir who influences the decedent to make, withdraw, or a will through fraud or coercion, or engages in forgery, alteration, concealment, or destruction of a will, may lose inheritance rights.
Severe abuse or insult to the decedent: Physical or mental suffering inflicted on the decedent, including physical abuse or malicious neglect of duty to provide care, can lead to disinheritance.

III. Case Study: Disputes over Inheritance Rights of Unfilial Children

Case of Unfilial Children

Mr. Liu, a law-abiding public servant with considerable wealth, raised a son with much affection. Despite being cherished, when Mr. Liu became bedridden and weak, relying solely on his spouse, his son neglected him for years without valid reasons. The question arises: Can the son inherit Mr. Liu's estate after his passing?

Judicial Perspective

The judiciary views long-term neglect of a bedridden parent without a valid reason as a severe form of abuse. This behavior falls under Article 1145, Paragraph 1, Item 5 of the Civil Code: "Severe abuse includes physical or mental suffering inflicted on the decedent. This encompasses physical abuse or willful neglect of duty to provide care. Continual neglect of a bedridden parent until their death, without valid reasons, is considered a serious abuse." (Refer to Supreme Court Case No. 1870, 1985).

From this, it is understood that continual neglect, especially in cases a parent is bedridden and the child fails to visit without a valid reason, constitutes severe abuse. In the case of Mr. Liu, his son could be legally disqualified from inheriting Mr. Liu's estate due to his failure to visit without a valid reason.

IV. How to Avoid Inheritance Disputes: Preventive and Resolution Strategies

Inheritance disputes often involve complex emotions and legal issues among family members. To prevent and resolve these disputes, the following strategies can be adopted:

Types of Strategies	Content Description
Clear Will Drafting	Assisted by a professional lawyer in drafting, clearly specifying the distribution of assets and heirs to ensure its legality and enforceability.
Family Communication and Mediation	Regularly hold family meetings to discuss inheritance and property issues, seeking family mediation or professional consultation when necessary to resolve disputes peacefully.
Establishment of Property Trusts	Establish trusts to designate trustees for managing and distributing assets, ensuring that the property is distributed according to the settlor's wishes.
Legal Consultation and Planning	Regularly consult legal professionals for legal and effective planning of family assets, providing advice on estate planning, tax handling, and more.
Legal Resolution Approaches	When disputes cannot be resolved through family communication, seek legal avenues such as filing a lawsuit or settling out of court.
Regular Updating of Wills and Estate Plans	As time progresses and family circumstances change, regularly wills and estate plans to ensure that the plans always reflect the current family situation and intentions.

V. Common Questions about Loss of Inheritance Rights

Q1: Under what circumstances can children lose their inheritance rights due to unfilial behavior?

A: According to Article 1145 of Taiwan's Civil Code, children may lose their inheritance rights for actions such as intentionally causing the death of the decedent, influencing the making of a will through fraud or coercion, forging or concealing a will, and significant abuse or insult to the decedent. In particular, long-term failure to visit or care for parents who are bedridden can be considered severe psychological abuse, leading to the loss of inheritance rights.

Q2: If parents have not explicitly stated their intention to disinherit an unfilial child, does the child still have a right to inherit?

A: According to the Supreme Court's Case No. 1250, Year 22, the decedent's behavior and expressions during their lifetime can be implicit, not limited to explicit wills or written expressions. If parents have implicitly indicated through their actions, such as expressing dissatisfaction or excluding the child from estate planning, that they do not wish to leave their property to a specific child, this can be interpreted as an implicit disapproval of the child's inheritance, potentially resulting in the loss of their inheritance rights.

Q3: How can one prevent and resolve inheritance disputes within the family?

A: Besides the previously mentioned strategies of writing wills and establishing property trusts, if you or your family members are facing inheritance-related issues, especially in cases involving unfilial children who may lose their inheritance rights, seeking professional legal assistance is crucial. It is highly recommended to contact an experienced lawyer for professional advice and legal support tailored to your individual situation. Professional lawyers can provide legal guidance, assist with effective property planning, and resolve inheritance disputes. Remember, appropriate legal assistance can bring harmony in family relationships and secure your assets. Do not hesitate to seek professional legal help immediately to ensure your rights are properly addressed.

Reference Material:司法院全球資訊網

Related Regulations: 民法繼承篇章

>Contact

Our Services